top of page

Internal Fraud in Credit Unions: Why Strong Controls Matter When Resources Are Limited

Writer: Griffin & Furman, LLC
Griffin & Furman, LLC
3 minutes ago
3 min read

Internal fraud can be difficult to detect, particularly when established procedures create a sense of security without providing meaningful oversight.


For smaller credit unions, limited staffing and overlapping responsibilities can increase this risk. Employees may perform multiple operational functions, maintain longstanding access to financial systems, or handle duties that would ideally be separated among several individuals.


The National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) identifies several measures to deter insider fraud, including:


  • Establishing and enforcing a fraud policy

  • Properly segregating duties

  • Maintaining appropriate bond coverage and conducting background checks

  • Implementing effective internal controls


However, having internal controls in place does not necessarily mean they are operating effectively.


The Difference Between Having Controls and Having Effective Controls


Internal controls are only as effective as the oversight behind them. According to Associate Partner Angela Warden, one commonly overlooked weakness is the review of system-generated reports. Employees may complete these reviews as required without thoroughly examining unusual activity or investigating potential discrepancies.


A consistent absence of documented exceptions or follow-up questions may indicate that reviews have become routine rather than meaningful.


Completing a review is not enough; it must involve meaningful scrutiny of account activity and potential irregularities.


How Limited Resources Create Hidden Vulnerabilities


Limited staffing can make segregation of duties difficult, particularly when employees are responsible for multiple financial and operational functions.


Through Griffin & Furman's agreed-upon procedures (AUP) engagements, Warden has identified several areas that warrant closer attention:


  • File maintenance and authorization reviews

  • Dormant account monitoring

  • Loan originations

  • Employee and insider account activity

  • General ledger adjustments


When responsibilities cannot be adequately separated, independent oversight becomes especially important.


Warden recommends periodic independent testing and active supervisory committee involvement to help address these vulnerabilities.


These measures provide an additional layer of protection when staffing limitations prevent traditional segregation of duties.


Why Past Engagement Results May Create a False Sense of Security


A report with no significant findings can provide reassurance, but it should not be viewed as a comprehensive assessment of fraud. As Warden explains, AUP engagements report factual findings based on specific procedures performed rather than providing an overall opinion on internal control effectiveness.


Credit unions should view AUP findings to identify areas requiring additional attention rather than relying on past results as confirmation that existing safeguards are sufficient.


The Importance of Independent Oversight


Independent testing can reveal weaknesses that may go unnoticed during routine operations.


Through AUP engagements, Griffin & Furman’s team has identified concerns involving dormant account activity, that was not adequately monitored, excessive employee fee reversals, unsupported file maintenance changes, and incomplete loan documentation.


These findings demonstrate why established procedures should be supported by independent verification.


Warden also emphasizes that supervisory committees play an important role in ensuring identified weaknesses are addressed.


During Griffin & Furman's quarterly supervisory committee presentations, previously identified action items are revisited to determine whether corrective measures have been implemented and whether unresolved concerns require further attention.


Identifying a weakness is only effective when corrective action follows.


Questions Credit Union Leadership Should Be Asking


Credit union executives and supervisory committees should regularly evaluate the following:


  1. If an employee concealed an unauthorized transaction, which controls would identify it, and who would investigate?

  2. Which responsibilities depend on individual employees without sufficient independent verification?

  3. Are previous AUP findings being used to improve monitoring and address recurring weaknesses?

  4. Have changes in staffing, technology, or transaction activity introduced new vulnerabilities?

  5. Are identified exceptions consistently investigated and resolved?


Warden recommends using AUP findings to identify reports and operational areas that warrant additional testing.


A targeted testing plan allows credit unions to focus limited resources on higher risk-activities without necessarily increasing staffing or operating expenses.


Strengthen Your Credit Unions Prevention Efforts


Griffin & Furman’s credit union team provides AUP engagements and targeted testing tailored to your institution’s needs. Contact our team to discuss how we can support your credit union’s internal control and oversight efforts.


Insights Provided By: Associate Partner Angela Warden

Comments


417 N. Theard St., Covington, LA 70433 |  985-727-9924

Photography by JSB Productions, LLC

© 2026 by Griffin & Furman, LLC and secured by Wix

Fax: 985-234-9194

Clean Biz Partnership BW
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page